Official Chinese activity data for the first couple of months is usually grouped together given the shifting timing of Chinese New Year each year. The 2013 data have also been released on a weekend, post the National People's Congress.
While there are signs of strength in some sectors, the problem now becomes too much of a good thing as the perception will be that loose money is blowing bubbles in the property sector. Industrial activity, on the other hand, remains fairly subdued and power generation very weak.
The ebb of IP growth to 9.9%YoY isn't too surprising given the small pull back in the PMI data. Looking at the MoM data, it actually looked quite weak in Jan at just 0.6%MoM, while Feb was about the same as the run rates at the end of 2012 at 0.8%.
What is surprising is how weak power generation was at just 3.4%YoY. Given it was very cold in January and industrial activity was statistically better in February, I would have expected it to be higher than this. The divergence between power and IP, however is nothing new. Although it is strange given things like steel and cement production where comparatively heathy.
Steel production is up a strong 14.2%YoY on the NBS numbers, which gels with what we have seen in the CISA production through the months. Some of this is because things like auto production are doing quite well, which is up 12.4%YoY.
But more importantly, the property market has improved dramatically, with sales sky rocketing and area under construction again turning positive.
The problem with this development is that policymakers are likely to be nervous that loose policy is having an unwelcome effect on housing markets. While a stabilisation in sales and activity would be a welcome development following loosening, it would appear that housing markets are doing much more than that.
And if policymakers are nervous, investors are likely to be increasingly so.
When you add the huge growth in social finance in January, it doesn't paint a picture of sustainable activity that everyone wants to see.
Showing posts with label housing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label housing. Show all posts
Sunday, 10 March 2013
China data deluge: property surge now creating more risks than rewards
I am an economics and commodities analyst currently working in New York City. Views expressed on this blog represent those of the author.
Please contact me for permission if you wish to use any of this information on this blog.
Wednesday, 20 February 2013
S&P kiss of death for Chinese property sector?
The FT reports that S&P have upgraded their outlook for the Chinese property sector to stable on the back of strong sales and house prices and stable financing for developers. But given S&P's ratings form in recent years, is this really a good sign?
In some ways many measurements of risk are usually counter to reality, with risk at its highest level precisely when it is perceived to be lowest. Ratings agency almost aways miss the boat as well and are a lagging indicator of risks to whatever they are rating.
To be sure, for those looking for those critical investment inflection points, perhaps this is one of those signs that things are too good. This coupled with the announcement of property curbs may suggest the best of Chinese housing market performance is now behind us.
This view might be a little too clever and not all of the better news for housing developers comes from better market activity. Developers are in better financial shape than a few years ago, reducing loans as a proportion of funding and lifting self-raised funding. This reduces the risk of a leverage induced meltdown if markets turn down.
But we may be getting close to the point to where good news in this sector is bad for markets as it leads to government tightening.
In some ways many measurements of risk are usually counter to reality, with risk at its highest level precisely when it is perceived to be lowest. Ratings agency almost aways miss the boat as well and are a lagging indicator of risks to whatever they are rating.
To be sure, for those looking for those critical investment inflection points, perhaps this is one of those signs that things are too good. This coupled with the announcement of property curbs may suggest the best of Chinese housing market performance is now behind us.
This view might be a little too clever and not all of the better news for housing developers comes from better market activity. Developers are in better financial shape than a few years ago, reducing loans as a proportion of funding and lifting self-raised funding. This reduces the risk of a leverage induced meltdown if markets turn down.
But we may be getting close to the point to where good news in this sector is bad for markets as it leads to government tightening.
I am an economics and commodities analyst currently working in New York City. Views expressed on this blog represent those of the author.
Please contact me for permission if you wish to use any of this information on this blog.
Sunday, 10 February 2013
Aus eco: Housing finance the latest disappointing data point
Housing finance slipped again in December. Some of the weakness in the headline numbers was due to refinancing, which isn't so important to growth, but even still the data weren't encouraging. First home owner activity also slipped further on the expiry of grants in several states in late 2012.
Couple this with the soft building approvals data and the recovery in housing market activity looks tentative at a stretch. It is certainly not enough to bank on to drive growth when mining related investment starts to shrink.
House prices are higher, but does that really matter so much for growth at the moment? It is not being driven by a strong increase in borrowing or credit growth. Consumers are also much more cautious than the free-wheeling days before the 2008 crash, with the latest retail sales data showing volumes only just growing over the quarter. Secondary housing market turnover is also not particularly high.
So these data today make it much more likely that the RBA will cut rates again if they want growth to get close their 2-3% forecast for 2013.
Couple this with the soft building approvals data and the recovery in housing market activity looks tentative at a stretch. It is certainly not enough to bank on to drive growth when mining related investment starts to shrink.
So these data today make it much more likely that the RBA will cut rates again if they want growth to get close their 2-3% forecast for 2013.
I am an economics and commodities analyst currently working in New York City. Views expressed on this blog represent those of the author.
Please contact me for permission if you wish to use any of this information on this blog.
Sunday, 13 January 2013
Aus housing recovery looking more "modest"
In the minutes of the RBA's December meeting, the board pointed to a "modest recovery" in housing investment, with "tentative" signs of an upturn. The latest data for November suggests this up-tick is looking even more modest.
Housing approvals for owner occupied housing slipped 0.5%MoM, with the survey suggesting little improvement from November across different segments of borrowing. Building approvals data were similarly uninspiring. A spike in the volatile apartment approvals series drove a gain in the month, although private sector dwellings were down 0.3%MoM after not doing very much over the past few months.
There is not much evidence that the cut in October spurred much housing market interest, with more recent stats on confidence and auction clearances suggesting the same for the December rate cut. The big question is whether this is enough to spur additional rate cuts in the near future. Certainly the last communique from the RBA suggests they are non-committal on further action in the very near future. Although most commentators feel otherwise, with forecasters looking for a further 50-75bps of cuts this year. This would take the level of mortgage rates down to levels seen in 2009.
To me it seems that the RBA will be less forthcoming than this and is definitely in no hurry to get to these kinds of levels. This has been the most subdued rate cutting cycle in recent memory and perhaps there is more to be gleamed from looking at periods when the RBA have slowly hiked rates than when they have aggressively cut.
In particular, the long tightening cycle from 2002 to 2009 saw the RBA wait for long periods before making small adjustments. Furthermore there was much debate about whether monetary policy could slow the economy down.
Slowly but surely rates did get to a level which had a big impact on activity, but the RBA was in no rush to get there. Perhaps there are more parallels today with that strategy than more recent easing cycles.
To me it seems that the RBA will be less forthcoming than this and is definitely in no hurry to get to these kinds of levels. This has been the most subdued rate cutting cycle in recent memory and perhaps there is more to be gleamed from looking at periods when the RBA have slowly hiked rates than when they have aggressively cut.
In particular, the long tightening cycle from 2002 to 2009 saw the RBA wait for long periods before making small adjustments. Furthermore there was much debate about whether monetary policy could slow the economy down.
Slowly but surely rates did get to a level which had a big impact on activity, but the RBA was in no rush to get there. Perhaps there are more parallels today with that strategy than more recent easing cycles.
I am an economics and commodities analyst currently working in New York City. Views expressed on this blog represent those of the author.
Please contact me for permission if you wish to use any of this information on this blog.
Wednesday, 19 December 2012
bounce in chinese housing underpins better 2013
The headline economic data from China often seem to belie the severity of the movements in activity and the reaction from many markets. Take the PMI and industrial production data. While both have shown a downtrend for most of this year, it hasn't been particularly alarming.
The HSBC PMI showed a small improvement on the flash estimate in December, suggesting a modest tick up in industrial production in the current month.
Other data sets perhaps show a better picture of what is happening, particularly to heavy industry. Electricity production, for example, has been much weaker than industrial production. This is now swinging back off the lows, albeit off a low base.
Many look to iron ore as a key barometer of Chinese activity given how leveraged it is to Chinese demand. After collapsing in August, iron ore has begin to tick back towards $140/t after its initial bounce back to $120/t.
Movements in inventories have played a key part in first the collapse and the more recent bounce, with crude steel production, as reported by the NBS, actually been relatively flat when accounting for seasonality.
Estimating Chinese steel production at this time of year is tricky as a number of small mills have in the past under-reported production in the final quarter of the year.
It does appear that production has firmed though, with higher-frequency from CISA showing an improvement from ~80% of mills. So the crude steel production outlook does appear to be improving into 2013.
Some maybe concerned that this is also just a function of stock shifting that is not sustainable. But while the headline IP data have been relatively benign, there has been a much more momentous change in residential housing markets.
Home sales have surged back in the past few months and as of November are rising ~20%YoY. With house prices also shifting higher, developers appear to be on steadier ground.
There is a lag before this feeds through to construction (which is still negative). However, the shift in sentiment and likely improvement in construction activity means that this part of the economy will shift from a drag on activity to a significant positive. This is particularly good news for iron ore, which looks to be solid around current prices.
I am an economics and commodities analyst currently working in New York City. Views expressed on this blog represent those of the author.
Please contact me for permission if you wish to use any of this information on this blog.
Monday, 10 December 2012
aus housing finance: monetary policy getting some traction
Housing finance data released today for November were poor on the MoM headline data, with the number of owner-occupied approvals rising just 0.1%MoM and 3.3%YoY. At face value this may suggest the RBA hasn't had much traction on housing markets. There are, however, some rays of hope
Looking more broadly at the value of total housing finance, which also includes investors, approvals rose 5.1% in the 3 months to October. Investors appear to have been more active, with finance for rent or resale rising, 7% over the same period.
The most powerful source of growth from lower interest rates is from stimulating housing construction, which has been weak over the past few years.
Refinancing has had an impact on the headline data, which is less important in terms of generating growth. Excluding this, owner-occupied data rose 7.6%YoY on a 3-month moving average basis (3mma). Much of this growth has come from new home sales, which are up very strong since mid-year and 28%YoY 3mma, which is encouraging for developers.
Looking more broadly at the value of total housing finance, which also includes investors, approvals rose 5.1% in the 3 months to October. Investors appear to have been more active, with finance for rent or resale rising, 7% over the same period.
The most powerful source of growth from lower interest rates is from stimulating housing construction, which has been weak over the past few years.
These data do show a large increase in finance for new dwellings, but does appear to be due to one large complex rather than a sustainable trend. We would expect this to drop away next month, but will be worth monitoring.
So these data are not particularly strong with many concerned the RBA is pushing on a string. This maybe an exaggeration, especially given the rate of easing has been relatively slow compared to previous periods. There has also been further easing in the past few months.
The question of whether the RBA needs to ease more aggressively really depends on whether the potential potholes in growth elsewhere are looming faster and larger than previously thought. There is a risk that this will be the case, although given unemployment remains low and overall GDP growth is ok, the RBA is unlikely to be looking for the panic switch.
I am an economics and commodities analyst currently working in New York City. Views expressed on this blog represent those of the author.
Please contact me for permission if you wish to use any of this information on this blog.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)















