Showing posts with label PMI. Show all posts
Showing posts with label PMI. Show all posts

Monday, 4 August 2014

Diverging PMIs lead the way for diverging policy

PMI data in the US and China improved in July, while Japan and Europe remain too close to stall speed for anyone's liking.

The diverging fortunes of the PMIs sets the scene for diverging paths for policymakers over the next 12 months. The Fed will be looking to take its foot of the accelerator, China to reconsider the real vs. financial growth tradeoffs, while Europe and Japan will continue to try to stoke economic activity.

The strong US ISM index gels nicely with most of the other indicators out of the US at present, which have been showing better momentum. This is setting the Fed on a path to raising rates next year.

The latest China PMI data also confirms stabilisation in activity following efforts of policymakers to stem the downside risks emerging at the start of year.

This is, however, coming at the expense of failing to deal with the mounting financial risks, with credit growth bouncing back very strongly in the past few months.

This is not sustainable and will either end with a big market induced crash or a more managed period of weakness due to policy restraint.  It seems likely that policy makers will step in to cool things down, perhaps heading into the end of this year.

The ECB still looks like it has some work to do given the pace of improvement in activity remains slow and the downside risks to inflation worrisome.  The failure of the Euro to meaningfully weaken is a particular problem for large French manufacturers, where PMI data points to declining activity.

Global industrial production should hold up reasonably well given the strength in the two biggest countries in China and the US.

But the diverging fortunes will have important implications for financial markets and currencies.

Monday, 2 June 2014

PMIs unspectacular but stable

The latest round of PMI data were on balance better than last month, with Chinese and US data improving and Japan showing stabilisation following the crunch in May.  Momentum in Europe, however, is poor considering the starting point.

The rise in both the official and HSBC China PMI suggests activity is perhaps a bit more stable than many have been fearing. For example, the current trajectory of the PMI data is better than the same period in 2012.
It is notable that the export index remains at sub-50 levels despite the ongoing improvement in developed economies. We have yet to see a bounce in the Chinese external sector, even though the RMB is weaker.
Its encouraging that the Japanese PMI is showing signs of stabilisation after the VAT hike induced fall last month.  Perhaps the Japanese economy has a bit more resilience than many believe, although its only early stages.

Not so encouraging is the lower levels of activity seen in the Euro area.  Activity was never particularly strong coming out of the recession and is now losing momentum.  This reinforces the need for more action from the ECB.
The release of the US ISM index was a farce, with ISM incorrectly applying seasonal factors in the first release.  In the end, it was stronger along with better new orders and production indices.

It does appear that US manufacturing has a bit of momentum bouncing out of the winter doldrums.
The stable China data is clearly welcome for commodities given its the centre of concern for metal markets.  Ex-China demand has been somewhat of an afterthought given its been steadily positive.

The most recent data show thats still the case, although momentum is not particularly great, particularly in Europe.  This is not the main game for commodities like copper, but is important at the margin, particularly for stocking activity.

Thursday, 1 May 2014

May PMI data: understanding the ISM, Japan PMI tanks

The US ISM index crept higher in April, although the closely-watched differential between new orders and inventories suggests this strength may not last.  It is worth taking a closer look at this relationship, as the dynamics appear to have changed since 2009 from the prevailing 20 years.

In the last 4 or so years, we have seen a more frequent narrowing in the gap between the new order and inventory components, which historically lead to a fall in the headline index, usually to below 50 levels.

But weakness in this differential doesn't appear to be as useful a leading indicator of the headline index.

This seems to be mostly due to the inventory index, which is now more volatile at a high level than in the past an dis much more frequently above 50.

Part of this maybe structural, with the gains of globalising supply chains approaching is maximum, with the downturn exposing problems with such a disaggregated approach to manufacturing.

It also maybe a function of patchy demand.  This current period of inventory and new order changes is not only different to 1990's onwards, but also from the 1970s and 1980s.  Back then, we saw wilder swings in inventories, but also bigger movements in new orders.

So it  does appear that old relationships aren't as meaningful as they once were, or at least require an additional look at the data.

Elsewhere, some of the PMI data won't be released until Monday thanks to a public holiday, but the flash estimates released a week ago should be around right.  In China the official index lifted a little to 50.4 and is still above the HSBC measure.

This is not unusual and is probably tracking the 2012 experience at present.  While this wasn't a disaster for the Chinese economy, it was a period commodity prices were weak.

Also of note is the big fall in the Japan PMI on the introduction of the consumption tax rise in April.  As a preliminary sign of what it means for growth this year, its clearly not a good one.

Tuesday, 1 April 2014

PMIs: China still soft, ex-China inflection point

The latest round of PMI data showed that the degree of weakness seen in the US at the start of 2014 was largely due to weather, while indices in EU and Japan were a bit lower than last month. While this suggests growth is still decent, there does appear to be an inflection point in the trajectory of activity.

Chinese PMI data were divergent, with the official number a little higher and the HSBC number weaker. This is not unusual in periods when demand is slowing.  It still seems conditions are weak, although there are tentative since of stabilisation in things like coal burn statistics.

The seasonality in the official PMI data has become less clear in the last few years, although some of the components continue to show more seasonality than others.  The employment component, for example, usually troughs in Jan and rises in March after Chinese New Year.  This year is no different although the gains have been weak, perhaps speaking to broader weakness.

The headline US ISM index was solid, recording a gain, reversing a big chunk of the losses seen since the start of the year.

That said, most of the gains was due to the jump in production from very weak levels in February. When looking at the new orders - inventory components, it suggests growth is moving to a slower track than the end of 2013.

PMI indices for Japan and Europe are also a little lower, although do remain in growth territory.  Thats enough to make full year growth numbers look strong for these countries.  But while that may drive results in spreadsheets based on annual numbers, its not what drives market outcomes.

This is particular important for commodities, especially when thinking about the trajectory of supply and inventories.  A slow down in the rate of growth in demand against steady growth in supply will change the rate at which inventories build or diminish, which will ultimately impact prices.

As an example, it looks like ex-China copper demand is moving past the inflection point of maximum growth, although not dramatically so. But this will be important to watch in the next few months, particularly as Chinese demand continues to look shaky.

As an indication of this, shanghai copper premiums have continued to tumble this week, quoted at ~$80-90/t

Monday, 3 February 2014

China and US fade out in focus in PMI data

The big miss on the US ISM and the weaker China PMI data were the key area of focus in the latest round of leading indicators. It wasn't entirely bad news, however, with Japan and the EU showing decent expansions.

The US ISM index is the latest piece of US data that has been on the weaker side, along with softer housing market data, durable goods and the poor payrolls result for December.

Most are pointing to the cold weather as playing a key role as it has in other data.  Weaker activity is also likely to be a function of high inventories, that have risen quite a bit into end 2013s.

Looking at the bigger picture, activity in the US has been patchy for a couple of years, so perhaps this is the first sign of another fade out.  It cannot be ruled out, although one month of data doesn't make a trend.  And at this stage its probably not going to sway the FOMC from their current tapering schedule, especially when market interest rates have fallen in the last few weeks.

The China PMI data were also weaker, but elicited a wider range of reaction for such a small move in the index.  The IMF response in this blog post from the Asia Pac division chief is the typical bullish view and is surprisingly less measured than most commentary you see published from the IMF.  The bear response is that its the beginning of the great unravelling on the Chinese economy given the gyrations in financial markets.

In some ways the gyrations in SHIBOR markets is normal, with rates also spiky when the PBC tightened liquidity in early 2011.  The problem now though is the flow on effects are much larger given the explosive growth in shadow financing, which is largely done relative to interbank rates.

So it will pay to be continue to be cautious on the downside risks to Chinese growth.  This doesn't mean you have to believe a crash is imminent. But certainly the risk of that is increasing and the starting point on overall growth is fairly sanguine at end 2013.

The better news was contained in the EU and Japanese data, which both saw chunky gains.  In some ways this mix of strength and weakness is not so bad, given both the US and China are in a better position to deal with slower growth than Japan and Europe.

But overall the data are bearish, not withstanding the large movement we have already seen in markets.


Tuesday, 1 October 2013

Chinese steel production still strong despite PMI miss

The latest data from CISA on 10-day average production showed very strong production rates to 20 September, rising close to 14%YoY compared to the same period last year.

The comps do get a little harder in the coming months and there is a the prospect of under reporting in November/December given the strength of production in the YTD and the ongoing government clamp downs on overcapacity in the sector.  But nonetheless, demand looks like it will be strong.

This is in contrast to the signal given by the latest round of PMIs, with the flash result revised down and the official number coming in a little lower than expected.

This isn't a disaster given August was quite a bit better than expected. But it does suggest that overall manufacturing is not doing as well as steel intensive sectors.  Perhaps this is to do with the external sector, although the leading indicators suggests exports throughout the Asian region should start rising soon.

Tuesday, 3 September 2013

Global manufacturing steps up a gear

The latest PMI data were all positive, with all key regions showing strength.   With the western world showing signs of improvement from a weak 1H13 and China proving to be stronger than anticipated, the top-down macro picture for commodities demand is good. Supply dynamics will sort the relative winners and losers, but its tough to be short in such an environment.

First, both the HSBC and official Chinese PMI data were better and at good levels for this time of year. There have been no signs that the SHIBOR squeeze a couple of months ago has had a material impact on manufacturing.  If anything, activity has actually strengthened.  This is also apparent in higher-frequency indicators like steel production and coal burn.

Of note is that the new orders component of the official PMI made a huge contribution to the gains in the headline index in the month.  Its hard to fault the gains in the headline index when it is driven by new business rather than the inventory cycle or strong goods production that ends up on shelves rather than consumed.

The Eurozone data were a little better than the flash data, with France now the real laggard from a manufacturing perspective.  The improvement in the EU is has more of an impact on commodity demand than the US for most metals, with the chart on the left weighted by copper consumption.  

The leading indicators for the US continue to look very bright, with both the headline and underlying components of the ISM index looking healthy.  

Actual manufacturing in the US has been pretty poor of late, showing no expansion from levels seen at the start of the year.  But this weakness now seems to be fading and it looks like manufacturing in the developed world will be much stronger in the second half of 2013 than the first.

Yields jumped on the release of the ISM, which has been taken as another hurdle jumped to for the Fed to start tapering.  Payrolls this Friday will be more instrumental in guiding markets bond markets. 

Markets do seem increasingly convinced that the Fed will slow bond purchases, although there hasn't been any strong signals from key players on the FOMC on a change in September.  But it does seem to be getting to a point where it is not that important whether its September or December, its clear that markets have mostly priced in the change in view from the Fed on the balance of risks to the outlook. Timing of tapering will probably be second to communication, which the Fed is likely to be extra wary of given they have been surprised by the bond sell-off in the last few months.

For industrial commodities, individual demand/supply dynamics may call for being more bearish than bullish.  But I would be very hesitant to short metals when leading indicators in every part of the world are pointing to improving demand.  

For copper, it seems that the better news from China has already driven out speculative short interest, with the balance between bulls and bears about even.  While strong mine supply for copper is an issue, I am not so sure this will undermine prices when the more visible demand indicators are getting better.


Thursday, 22 August 2013

Flash PMIs on the up

Both the China and EU flash PMI were better in August.  For Europe, this is a continuation of the slow path back to growth over the last few months.  The China PMI was more of a surprise and is one of a number of indicators that suggests while growth is slowing, its currently not as alarming as many would have feared a couple of months ago.

The weakness in the HSBC PMI last month did roil markets upon its release, but it was still a bit higher than July last year.  The most recent reading of 50.1 is a big leap relative to what we saw at the same point last year.

The doesn't appear to be any definitive data to suggest activity has been badly damaged by the retraction in broader credit availability following the squeeze in SHIBOR a few months ago.  If anything, many indicators have proven to be a bit stronger, with things like housing construction and steel production surprising to the upside.

The European PMI data were a little uneven; the German manufacturing was strong, but the French PMI was unchanged at just under 50.

While growth is very welcome, when put in the context of the performance over the last few years the likely pick up is pretty poor.  Nevertheless the switch from drag to boost to activity from the Eurozone is probably more important to global GDP than the current problems plaguing some emerging markets.

Wednesday, 24 July 2013

China and EU flash PMIs in July

The flash PMI data for China were bad at face value, sinking to 47.7 in July.  But this was actually higher than the reading this time last year of 46.8.  While HSBC try to seasonally adjust the data, there is undoubtedly some seasonal affects in the data.  So its not quite as disastrous as it looks. 

What has changed from this time last year is not just the leadership, but also the perception that the new government is more tolerant of slower growth that the previous one.  This is starting to lead to a seachange in forecasts for China, shifting closer to 7% from 8% previously (see this post on consensus forecasts).

The better news is that it appears that European manufacturing is finally lifting declines, with PMI's printing above 50 for the first time since July 2011.  This is a shockingly long time for activity to be declining, with the subsequent pick up not looking at all strong.  This truly speaks to the corrosive nature of financial crisis and the folly of austerity to try and fix it.  But at least it seems the worst has past, not accounting for any policy blunders (which can't be counted out)

While for commodities the focus will be 100% on China, the return to growth in Europe is important for base metals in particular.  To be sure, just removing the drag on growth will be important to demand/supply balances and stocking cycles.  Balancing out both developments in these data, I think on balance its probably bullish rather than bearish.


Monday, 1 July 2013

Looking for renewed vigour in global IP

The global PMI data were a little bit better on balance in June, with the drag from Japan and Europe has come to an end.  But in the grand scheme of things, industrial activity is fairly weak with plenty of downside risks.

The Chinese PMI data were weaker in June, but don't look particularly bad.  It is way to early to gauge the impact of the recent interbank squeeze on activity and perhaps its initial affect won't be particularly big. The official PMI data and the HSBC series are about where they were this time last year. While that suggests growth is slowing, this in itself isn't need for additional concern.

While the PMI data are soggy, steel production remains surprisingly strong in mid-June.  The ongoing strong rates of activity, weak steel prices and excess inventories means that when the market does adjust, its increasingly likely to be nasty.

The EU PMI were stronger and manufacturing will be back in the expansion zone soon.  This is good news, although isn't a testament to good policy but rather activity crawling off a low base.  One welcome development in this months data is that the improvement in the EU wasn't driven by Germany but by everywhere else.  This is necessary for the Eurozone to claw its way out of the current abyss.

The US ISM survey was better, getting back above the 50 mark.  But there isn't anything in the details to suggest activity is particularly vibrant and US IP growth rates have slowed alot.  So things on the activity front are far from healthy.


Leading indicators suggests we should get a small lift in YoY global IP from current run rates as negatives from Japan and Europe fall out of the equation.  As things stand, that would lift growth rates to ~3-3.5%YoY.

That is not a total disaster, but in the context of recent weakness, it leaves activity at uninspiring levels for manufacturers.  And outside of Japan, it doesn't look like policy makers are looking to change the slower status quo for manufacturing.

Thursday, 20 June 2013

Focus switches to Chinese credit squeeze

While markets have been almost singularly focussed on Fed policy in recent weeks, something more interesting in brewing in China.  Interbank lending markets look to have been effectively closed, with SHIBOR (Shanghai Interbank Lending Rates) skyrocketing to extremely high levels.

The catalyst for this move appears to be reports that China Everbright failed to make repayments on short term money due to tight liquidity, which initially locked up markets.  The move was then amplified by the People's Bank of China surprising many by not providing additional liquidity into short term interbank markets to unlock the flow of credit.

Rumours are that the PBC are now providing targeted funding, but the actions of the PBC speak volumes of the change in policy direction from Chinese officials.  It is not slower growth and low inflation that are the key trade off, but the explosion of credit that has policy makers most concerned.

Chinese monetary policy is not as straight forward as in other countries, as officials have more control over certain aspects of credit flow. Traditionally, policymakers have been able to affect almost all parts of credit availability by enforcing credit quotas and interest rates at state-run financial institutions.  There was some constraints though, particularly in managing capital inflows required to keep the exchange rate on a desired path.

But more recently policy makers have been loosing their grip over the control of credit due to the rise of other sources of funding.  Lending from investment trusts has been very strong, while the use of undiscounted bankers acceptances (short term lending that can be moved off banks balance sheets) has also exploded in the year to date.

Squeezing interbank markets is aimed at pushing at speculative lenders out of the market. In particular, bankers acceptances should be affected by the drying up of short term credit, while trust lending is also reportedly a target.

This may cause a high level of concern amongst investors given spiking interbank rates were a feature of the financial crisis in 2008.  I think a key difference is that the PBC to some degree is more deliberately starving interbank markets of funding as it wants to drive out bad lending.  In 2008, policymakers were always fighting a loosing battle to keep markets propped up as the magnitude of the problem was different.

As a reminder of the risks to growth, the Chinese flash PMI was weak, at 48.3.  Its hard to gauge what this means, given its about where it was this time last year and things weren't disastrous then.
But it does appear that Chinese activity is slowing, which along with this credit squeeze is likely to send commodities and commodity currencies lower.


Monday, 3 June 2013

PMIs point to sluggish cycle

The Purchasing Managers' Indexes (PMIs), which are the single best barometer of the near term industrial cycle and general activity, were sluggish.  The continued fall in the US ISM index is probably the most important aspect of the data, suggesting growth has slowed after only a modest pick up earlier in the year.

While the headline US data were bad, the details were also concerning, with new orders and inventory data suggesting a stalling manufacturing sector.

This data is contrary to the strength in equity markets and certainly doesn't support the view of the need for tapering of QE from the Fed, which is currently being priced in to some degree in fixed income markets.  Markets didn't really react to the numbers at the end of the day, with payrolls looming at the end of the week to be a huge market mover.

The EU PMI data were less bad, with all countries contributing to the chunky rise in the headline regional number to 48.3, albeit still pointing to a contraction.  This is a welcome development for markets, but these data don't make a convincing case that the European struggle won't force a further need for much more significant policy intervention.

In contrast with the EU, Japan is actually embarking on an experiment of "whatever it takes" and the results from these data are encouraging.   The much weaker Yen is helping to lift Japanese activity and while it may to some degree be at the expense of other countries, I would argue that they are in a much better position to handle a stronger exchange rate than Japan is and thus Yen weakness is a very good thing.

The Chinese PMI data present the largest challenge for analysts.  The HSBC data was weak, but the official data were a bit more steady than expected.  Which one to believe is difficult, with the HSBC data probably having the better record in mirroring actual activity more closely.

The change to the sample size of the official PMI data may also have changed some of the observable seasonality in the data.  For example, when looking at the contribution to the monthly change in the PMI there has been some unusual trends in the last few months.

For example, New Orders, Production and Employment subcomponents, which account for 75% of the total headline index, are usually negative in May.  But this month these components were pretty flat.

Supplier inventories and materials were also very subdued in terms of contribution this month as well.

For commodities, while the headline number is good news, the fact that materials inventories aren't reportedly in general isn't particularly good news.  This is probably more reflective of an sector like steel, where inventories are currently too high, than of copper where destocking is happening.

China seems to be travelling along ok but probably still a bit weaker than expected despite recent downgrades to growth.  So overall, the data is not too inspiring for those looking for an upswing from the current grind.

Tuesday, 2 April 2013

Taking a closer look at the official Chinese PMI

While the official Chinese PMI went up, the miss on expectations will make many nervous, from copper bulls who need strong Chinese consumption to absorb rapidly building stocks and steel producers/traders who have accumulated large inventory on very strong production rates in early 2013.

Looking at the detail of the data, it does look like unusual movement in some of the components caused the headline to underwhelm.  Also for those concerned with commodities, falling materials inventory is not a bad thing, although it is a negative on the headline PMI.

The official PMI has this year been expanded to cover 3000 firms, but its construction remains the same.  As a diffusion index, each value represents the balance of positive responses (activity improving) vs. those responding negative and no change.  The headline index is a weighted index of 5 other components: New Orders (30%), Production (25%), Employment (20%), Supplier deliveries (15%) and Materials Inventories (10%).  Supplier deliveries are taken as a negative for the headline index, that is if the index rises (deliveries becoming faster), it makes a negative contribution to the PMI.

The headline Index is mostly driven by New Orders, Production and Employment. The chart on the left shows the monthly contribution from these components to the headline.  For example, for the most recent data point, New Orders, Production and Employment drove 1.5 index points of the total change in the headline index.

The chart highlights the March values over the last 4 years and shows that the most recent data is stronger than 2010 but weaker than last year.  So while its not particularly strong, these components probably haven't disappointed.



What was an usually large drag on the index was supplier deliveries and materials inventories. To be sure, the cumulative 0.6 index point drag from these components was the largest in the series history.

And while these are negative developments for the PMI, they are not particularly negative for the bigger picture.  While faster supplies could represent demand driven slack in the supply chain, it could also be a function of greater efficiency.

Falling materials inventories are also a good sign for those looking forward.  The inventories index has actually not been negative in March since the series began in 2005.

So the detail suggests that perhaps the miss in the headline PMI is not really bad news at all for commodities